It’s a question that’s been posed to the Commons Transport Select Committee by road safety charity Brake – which claims young drivers acting as “taxi drivers” for their friends directly contributes to serious accident rates.
Committee chairman Huw Merriman noted that young people account for 21% of car drivers killed or seriously injured – despite making up just 7% of licence holders.
Brake is in favour of a much talked-about phased driver licensing system, which would see new young drivers subject to certain restrictions on their activity.
Its chief executive Mary Williams says young drivers are "basically free commercial taxi drivers", contributing to the high casualty rates caused by the age group, which is also responsible for "killing vulnerable road users outside vehicles".
"If we consider young drivers as taxi drivers for their mates, then we need to consider them… as occupational drivers," she added.
"Then we start to think sensibly about a phased driver licensing system, in the same context that, for example, many of the fleet supporters of Brake do when they are training, evaluating and monitoring their novice and young commercial vehicle drivers."
Introducing restrictions on young drivers would prevent them from being pressured into giving lifts to friends as "it’s simply a matter of saying it’s against the law", according to Ms Williams.
"It’s giving young people that power to be safe and to protect the lives of other young people."
Currently the only special measure in place to deter new motorists is a law which strips them of their licence if they receive six penalty points within the first two years, rather than the standard 12 points.
As well as banning passengers, past proposals considered for graduated driving licences have involved driver curfews, lower alcohol limits and making the use of "P" plates mandatory – schemes already in place in the likes of the US, Canada, Australia and Sweden.
- Driving in the dark – tips on how to stay safe
- Dangerous driving – what it is and how to report it
- 17 things your driving instructor never taught you
Dr Neale Kinnear, head of behavioural science at the Transport Research Laboratory, told the committee that 122 fatalities could have been prevented between 2013 and 2018, had graduated licences been brought in following the last Department for Transport-commissioned review.
He said: "This really is a public health thing. It’s not just about an individual driver that we’re looking to try and prevent doing something bad. It’s actually protecting everyone that’s using the roads."
So what do you think? Would restricting new drivers from carrying passengers help reduce the number of serious road accidents? Let us know in the comments.
RAC Breakdown Cover Sale
With our cover, the difference is in your pocket.
*Max 40% applies to new Extra and Complete for 1 vehicle or 1 person. Ends 17/07/24, 7am. ^ £6.75 for Basic, not on sale.
